Blogs

Lights, Camera, Incorporate! Choosing the Best State for Your Film Business LLC

The bustling LA film production office buzzed with talk of expanding to NYC. Maya had just finished discussing her career prospects with her mother and accountant. With a trust fund generating substantial taxable income and future fees and bridge loans on the horizon, she aimed to make smart financial moves. Forming an LLC to manage her investments, income, and work-related expenses, like traveling the festival circuits, seemed logical. However, the question of where to incorporate – Delaware, New York, or California – lingered.

Maya was drawn to New York’s robust film and television tax credits and wanted a production office there. Despite Delaware’s business-friendly laws and tax advantages, the networking benefits of an LA-based company were appealing. As she swiveled in her chair, her eyes landed on the business card of a trusted New York City legal advisor. It was time to seek professional guidance and make a decision that would shape her future in the film industry.

In terms of top choices to form an LLC due to their favorable business climates, tax policies, privacy, regulatory environment, and filing fees and maintenance costs, here’s how Delaware, Nevada, and Wyoming compare to New York, California, and all other US states, especially if the company wants to attract outside or passive investors:

Delaware:

• Advantages: Well-established corporate law, strong reputation for investor protection, flexible corporate structure, no state corporate income tax for companies operating outside Delaware, and Chancery Court for business disputes. These factors make Delaware LLCs attractive to investors seeking a stable and predictable legal environment.

• Disadvantages: High franchise taxes compared to other states, no significant tax benefits for companies operating within Delaware, and perceived as a “tax haven” by some, which may deter some investors.

Nevada:

• Advantages: No state corporate income tax, no personal income tax, strong asset protection laws, and confidentiality for LLC owners. These benefits can be enticing for investors looking to minimize tax burdens and protect their assets.

• Disadvantages: Relatively high annual fees, less developed corporate law compared to Delaware, and may be perceived as less prestigious than a Delaware LLC.

Wyoming:

• Advantages: Low annual fees, strong asset protection laws, and high degree of privacy for LLC owners. This can be attractive to investors seeking maximum privacy and asset protection.

• Disadvantages: Less developed corporate law compared to Delaware, limited network of professionals specializing in Wyoming LLCs, and may be perceived as less prestigious than a Delaware LLC.

New York:

• Advantages: Large and diverse economy, access to a wide range of investors, robust film tax credits, and established legal framework. These factors can be attractive to investors seeking a location with a strong business ecosystem and potential for growth.

• Disadvantages: High taxes, complex regulations, and less flexible corporate laws compared to Delaware. These factors can deter some investors who prioritize lower costs and simpler legal structures.

California:

• Advantages: Thriving entertainment industry, large pool of potential investors, and strong consumer market. These factors can be attractive to investors seeking exposure to a large and dynamic market.

• Disadvantages: High taxes, complex regulations, less flexible corporate laws compared to Delaware, and high cost of living. These factors can deter some investors who prioritize lower costs and simpler legal structures.

Overall Comparison:

Delaware, Nevada, and Wyoming generally offer more favorable tax policies, privacy, and filing fees compared to New York and California. However, New York and California have larger economies and more diverse investor pools.

The choice of where to incorporate depends on the specific needs and priorities of the company and its investors. Factors to consider include the type of business, the target investor audience, and the desired level of privacy and asset protection.

Conclusion:

Delaware, Nevada, or Wyoming are popular choices, but forming the LLC in your home state might be simpler and more cost-effective.

For instance, if you are based in New York and involved in the film industry, having an LLC with a NY address can offer substantial networking and business advantages. The local presence can be crucial in your industry, potentially outweighing the monetary benefits of a Delaware LLC. Forming the LLC in your home state simplifies legal and administrative processes, avoiding the need to register as a foreign LLC and pay additional fees. While New York has higher taxes and fees, these can often be offset by the benefits of operating locally, such as easier management of expenses and compliance.